Greatest Yankee Second Baseman

[RickD]

Who was the greatest Yankee Second Baseman?

PLAYER	BA	HITS	RUNS	HR	RBI	SB	TITLES
Joe Gordon	.268	1,530	914	253	975	89	5
Tony Lazzeri	.292	1,840	986	178	1,191	148	5
Willie Randolph	.276	2,210	1,239	54	687	271	2
Bobby Richardson	.266	1,432	643	34	390	73	3
Alfonso Soriano	.282	1,264	721	241	630	229	0

[RickD]

Willi Randolph IMO.

[WilsonC]

I went with Gordon, but this one is really a toss-up between Gordon, Lazzeri, and Randolph. If you adjust for war-time service, I think Gordon comes out ahead. If you don't, then it could go to either Randolph or Lazzeri, depending on how you weigh Randolph's defense versus Lazzeri's offense.

The way Cano's career is going, he could make this discussion moot in a few years.

[munson15ny]

Tony Lazzeri

[soberdennis]

Poosh 'em Up in a close battle.

[Mudge]

Bobby Richardson. I don't really know why except he was one of the first baseball cards I ever got as a kid.