PDA

View Full Version : Weighing In: Historys Lightest and Heaviest Ballplayers



Mr. Baseball
06-06-2011, 10:29 AM
When I look back at rosters from the 19th century, it's hard to believe how much bigger baseball players have evolved over the last hundred years. Back in the glory days of Ty Cobb, the average ballplayer looks to be about 5'9 and weighs maybe 160 pounds. Today, it's rare to find a club with more than four players shorter than six foot. And under 5'10? At the very most, there might be twenty in the league (and that's a drastically over-estimated).

So this got me thinking, while all of us know about Eddie Gaedel the 65-pound midget that was used as a publicity stunt in 1951, I doubt many of us knew of Candy Cummings, a pitcher in the earlier days of the league.

Cummings, standing at 5'9 and weighing just 110 pounds in his earliest years, was a pitcher for six seasons in the Major Leagues. He wasn't bad either! In fact, Cummings was even elected to the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame! Posting a career win/loss record of 145-94, with an ERA of 2.42, it's safe to say he was "The Freak" of his time. Candy retired from the league in 1877 with the Cincinnati Reds, weighing 120 pounds. No player since, has ever been so light.

http://www.trueknowledge.com/images/thumbs/180/250/Candy_Cummings_Baseball.jpg

125 years later, Walter Young comes along. In 2005, when Young made his debut with the Baltimore Orioles, he weighed nearly 300 pounds. Heavy enough, and tall enough, to make Prince Fielder look tiny. For obvious heath concerns, Young has since shed 35-pounds.

http://www.baseball-almanac.com/players/pics/walter_young_autograph.jpg

RickD
06-06-2011, 10:35 AM
Wow...I heard of Candy Cummings and never heard of Walter Young. I am so needing to pay attention to baseball after 1980!

Mr. Baseball
06-06-2011, 10:39 AM
Wow...I heard of Candy Cummings and never heard of Walter Young. I am so needing to pay attention to baseball after 1980!

He hasn't played MLB ball in almost six years, so this is understandable. Not to mention you run the Virtual HOF Series. ;)

Old Sweater
06-06-2011, 07:59 PM
Candy Cummings gets most of his baseball recognition for inventing the curve.

BobH
06-06-2011, 08:42 PM
Fielder is listed at Baseball-Reference at 5'11" and 275lbs. That's fat! I remember Frank(Hondo) Howard who played from '58-'73. He weighed 255lbs. but at 6'7" he was a helluva man. Not an ounce of fat anywhere.-BH

Mickey Mental
06-07-2011, 12:56 AM
"A waist is a terrible thing to mind"...........Terry Forster

Years ago you could play in the majors with a name like Candy Cummings. Today you'd be just another porn star.

Cummings pretty much created that curveball at the age of 14.